Why the answers differ
- Different sources. An engine that searches the web cites the pages it found for that question; two engines can find different pages.
- Search or memory. An answer written from model knowledge reflects what the model learned before its cut-off, not what your site says today.
- Different wording of the answer. One engine may give a short list of three, another a longer comparison, so the number of businesses named differs.
- Run-to-run variation. The same engine changes its answer between runs. More on why answers change.
How to compare the engines fairly
- Use the same questions on every engine, written the way buyers ask them.
- Run each question more than once per engine and count how often you’re named, not whether you appeared once.
- Note which competitors each engine names; a competitor that appears everywhere is the one to study.
- Note the cited pages per engine. A page cited by two engines is worth more of your time than one cited once.
- Keep the date: answers change as pages and models change.
What to do with the differences
| What you see | Likely meaning | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Named on the searching engines, missing from the one answering from memory | Your recent pages are found, but you’re not well known yet | Keep earning mentions on the pages buyers and lists cite; this changes slowly |
| Missing on every engine | The cited pages don’t mention you, or your site isn’t readable | Start with crawler access and the most-cited pages |
| Named everywhere but with a wrong fact | A widely read page has old information | Trace and fix the wrong fact |
| Named on one searching engine only | The two engines rely on different pages | Compare their cited pages and get onto the ones you’re missing from |
Run the comparison in one go
The full CheckAIVisibility report asks 15 buyer-style questions on OpenAI and Claude with web search and on Gemini from model knowledge, 2 runs each, and shows the mention rate per engine side by side with the competitors and cited pages. You can see the format in the example report. The free AI visibility check is a preview on OpenAI only.
ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini compared: FAQ
Why would two AI models name different businesses for the same question?
They are different models, they may read different pages when they search, and some answer from what the model already knows instead of searching. Even one model gives different answers between runs. So differences between engines are normal; the useful question is where you are missing and why.
Which engine matters most for my business?
The one your buyers use. If you don’t know, ask a few customers where they look things up. Testing all three costs little extra and stops you optimising for one engine while losing another.
Does CheckAIVisibility test the ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini apps?
No. It uses the official APIs: OpenAI and Claude models with web search, and a Gemini model from what it already knows. The consumer apps can add their own features, so app results can differ.
Does it test Perplexity or Google AI Overviews?
No. Those aren’t part of the check.
Is the free check enough to compare engines?
The free check runs 5 questions on OpenAI only. The engine comparison is in the full report, which runs the same 15 questions on all three, 2 times each, for a one-time $9.